Shabal: Jason Cottle
Cristo: Alex Veadov
Jackie Engle: Alisa Marshall
Relativity Media presents a
film directed by Mike McCoy and Scott Waugh. Written by Kurt Johnstad. Running
time: 111 min. Rated R (for strong violence including some torture, and for
language).
My father was a U.S. Marine
Corps fighter pilot. He passed away last year after a brief battle with cancer
that ravaged his body quickly. When he got sick, he kept a positive outlook. He
never complained about what was happening to him. When it got to the point that
he realized he wasn’t going to pull through, he accepted it and expected
everyone else to do the same. He faced his death as his military training had
prepared him, with dignity and as an uncompromising fact of life. He had served
his time and served it well. He died like the Marine he was.
The new movie “Act of Valor”
is dedicated to the men of the U.S. Navy Special Forces and all military personnel who
have given their lives in the service of their country. It honors all soldiers.
I mention my father in this review to show that I have the utmost respect for
the service these men provide to our country. I’m fearful of the world that
might thrive if these men weren’t dedicated to protecting the freedoms of our
country. I understand what kind of person it takes to commit such sacrifice for
our country. I mean no disrespect for what these men do.
That being said, “Act of
Valor” is a bold experiment that succeeds in many of its aspects, but fails
from a dramatic standpoint. Filmmakers Scott Waugh and Mike McCoy, through
their work making recruiting films for the Navy, conceived of a military action
drama starring active duty Navy SEALs. The Navy backed their idea and required
SEALs to participate in the film. SEAL Team 7 is featured in the movie, including
the starring roles. Their training makes them the best-suited people around to
pull off authentic action scenes based on military maneuvers. It does not
prepare them, however, to convincingly portray dramatic characters within a
cinematic story arc.
At the moment, I haven’t
been able to find the names of the men portraying SEAL Team 7 in this movie,
most likely because they are still active members of the unit. Perhaps this is
good when discussing the acting in the film. I’ll start off by saying they
aren’t the worst actors I’ve seen in legitimate dramatic movies, but they do
prove the point that acting isn’t as easy as it seems. They’ve got the love of
their country down. They’ve got the tactical language down. They’ve got
camaraderie mastered. Their personal dialogue and emotional output is a little
wooden, however. This unfortunately leads to a lack of emotional impact for the
whole of the film.
I won’t place the entire
blame on the SEALs’ untrained acting. The script, provided by “300” screenwriter
Kurt Johnstad, is clichéd and lacks any real emotional depth in itself. Even
the scenes involving professional actors are mired with posturing and simplistic ideals
in storytelling. The villain (Jason Cottle, “The Wedding Singer”), a terrorist
who plans an attack on U.S. soil, is like something out of a James Bond movie.
He flies off the handle at his own conspirators and his motivations don’t seem
to have much conviction behind them beyond “Death to the infidels!”
The plot seems like
something inspired more by Hollywood than actual terrorist activities. The
terrorists have devised a bomb device that I’m sure is out of every bomb
makers’ dreams, but seems unlikely to really exist. Perhaps these types of
devices do exist and finding them and shutting them down is part of what SEALs
do on a regular basis. I am not one to judge about that. Since this was made
with real SEALs in the roles of the heroes deployed to stop such plots, I’m
willing to believe that James Bond might be closer to the truth than we’d all
like to think.
What the movie gets right,
however, are the actual missions these men execute. The action sequences are
nothing less than stunning. The first rescue mission is a fascination to watch.
Everything the SEAL Team does, even when they have to change the plan, is
incredibly calculated. There are mistakes, but they are effortlessly accounted
for with adjustments that could only be conceived by professionals. Their use
of strategy against their opponents is awesome. Their detachment is a tool that
serves their missions. Seeing them at work is like seeing a different kind of
art than the acting for which I’m critical.
I wonder how the filmmakers
could’ve made this movie differently so they could achieve their objective of
making Hollywood style action sequences with dramatic elements surrounding them
that worked better. Perhaps a documentary style would’ve served their purposes
better. They could stage the action, as the filmmakers do in the climbing
documentary “Touching the Void”. This would allow for the same impact of the
harrowing nature of what these men do. Then the filmmakers could fill in around
the staged sequences with traditional documentary footage that showed the SEALs in a more genuine light than the scripted words do.
No comments:
Post a Comment