Michael Murphy: Taylor Kitsch
Danny Dietz: Emile Hirsch
Matt ‘Axe’ Axelson: Ben Foster
Shah: Yousuf Azami
Gulab: Ali Suliman
Erik Kristensen: Eric Bana
Shane Patton: Alexander Ludwig
Universal Pictures presents
a film written and directed by Peter Berg. Based on the book “Lone Survivor:
The Eyewitness Account of Operation Redwing and the Lost Heroes of Seal Team
10” by Marcus Luttrell and Patrick Robinson. Running time: 121 min. Rated R
(for strong bloody war violence and pervasive language).
As I walked into the theater
to see “Lone Survivor”, the true story of what happened to Seal Team 10 on an
Afghanistan mission that went wrong, the theater’s owner told me I needed to be
thankful for what the men depicted in the film have sacrificed for our country.
I am. This resonated again with me yesterday evening as I watched The Golden
Globe Awards, one of a half a dozen awards shows you see throughout the year
where the stars of Hollywood come out and praise each other for the great work
they’ve done. Two things struck me about the relation of this film and these
Hollywood award events. One is that, although during a show like the Golden
Globes it may appear as if the people involved with filmmaking do it for the
glory, they really aren’t in it for any more glory than the soldiers who give
their lives in the name of freedom. Two is that without this Hollywood glitz
and glamour—this PR machine that is designed more to sell the movies involved
than to truly honor the work of making them—we’d never know much about the fate
of Seal Team 10.
I think the U.S. military
understands the methods of Hollywood better than the American public. In an
interview on The Tonight Show last week, this film’s star, Mark Wahlberg,
revealed that the character he plays did not want to tell his story in the book
upon which the film is based. It was the U.S. military that urged him to write
the book so his story could be known to the American public. I wonder if the
movie deal was already in place. Either way, it was a brilliant move
considering our war in Afghanistan is not much understood here in the states.
Soldiers and the work they do are too often used as talking points in political
debates, and only through artistic endeavors like this and many other movies do
we truly try to understand their place in the way our world operates. “Lone
Survivor” is an invaluable tool put to this end.
The movie tells the story of
Operation Red Wings, which was executed in June of 2005. Seal Team 10 is
ordered to capture or kill a high-ranking Taliban leader thought to be in a
small mountain village. An elaborate plan is devised to carry out their mission
with a four man scouting team sent in to make a positive ID before pulling in the
rest of the team. These men are Marcus Luttrell, Danny Dietz, Matt ‘Axe’
Axelson and the team leader Michael Murphy.
A family of goat herders, consisting
of an old man and two children, discovers the four men as they hide out in the
mountains above the village. The old man has with him a communication device,
likely issued by the Taliban. Without being able to contact their superiors due
to the mountainous terrain playing havoc with their communication systems, the
four men have to decide among themselves what to do with these people who will
clearly give their location up to the Taliban if they let them go. After a vote,
Murphy decides to uphold the Rules of Engagement set forth by the Geneva
Convention, and he lets the shepherds go. Within an hour, Taliban forces
surround them. The mission has become one of survival.
Writer/director Peter Berg
takes Luttrell’s cue from the first chapters of the book and places a great
deal of emphasis on the bond of brotherhood shared by the soldiers. The opening
credits show photographs and footage of real Seal training and depicts the
camaraderie built up between the men in the process. He then gives us much more
background on these four men than is usually found in a war film, which have a
tendency to concentrate more heavily on the procedures of war. Much is made
about the personal lives that are waiting for these men back in the States.
The procedure is there as
well, as Berg takes us through every aspect of the prep for the operation. Axe
notes that there are “a lot of moving parts.” The details of the scout team’s
insertion and the way they check in with their base of operations are made
clear, so we know that every decision is made through the chain of command.
When they are discovered and can’t communicate through the chain of command, we
realize the predicaments of war that often defy the black and white nature of
the Rules of Engagement. Like brothers they disagree, by they work to what they
feel is the best solution. Berg expertly lays out all this for the audience to
discern.
The action sequences that
depict the team’s fight for survival against what can be referred to as
insurmountable odds are incredibly intense. To call these men as tough as they
come would be putting it in the most mild of terms. Their struggle amounts to
one of those audience experiences where you find yourself tearing at your own
hair, squirming in your seat and uttering guttural sounds as you try to take
some of the damage these men are enduring as partially your own.
Now, I don’t want to spoil
anything for anybody, and yet somehow I’m sure there is someone out there who
will find what I want to deal with next as a spoiler despite the film’s title;
but eventually, Luttrell is the only one of the four men left. While the
humanity and brotherhood of these men is the film’s focal point, what happens
next might be the primary reason the military wanted this story told. Luttrell
is rescued and hidden away by an Afghan from the very village in which the
Taliban leader was hiding. The man protects Luttrell out of an Afghanistan
belief called Pashtunwali, which dictates that an honorable man must defend and
protect the weak and grant asylum to one from his enemies. This humanity in the
Afghan people is what is truly important to the military about our fight in
Afghanistan. Berg wants us to know we are not sending our soldiers there to a
people who don’t appreciate us, as the media coverage often implies.
2 comments:
Nice review Andrew. Berg may not always be my favorite director out there, but he shows that he can shoot an action-scene and make it as brutal and raw as they come.
Yeah. Berg doesn't often impress me either. Probably this one and Friday Night Lights (the movie, I couldn't sit through the TV series) are his two best efforts.
Post a Comment